Cash payment lightens sentence for Australian murderer (Updated June 14, 2010)

A 61-year-old former Perth resident will serve just two years and nine months imprisonment for the murder of a 46-year-old Hawaii resident in the northern Thailand city of Chiang Mai after making a cash payment of Bt100,000 (US$2,955) to a woman who claimed to be the girlfriend of the victim in a trial that lasted less than three hours.

William Thomas Douglas, formerly of Willetton, pleaded guilty in the Chiang Mai Provincial Court to shooting Gary Bruce Poretsky at the Keari restaurant on the morning of March 22, this year and was sentenced to four years imprisonment for murder, one year for having an unregistered firearm and a further six months for carrying a firearm in public.

However, because he confessed to the crime and pleaded guilty he received a 50 per cent reduction in the sentence.

Hawaiian resident Gary Poretsky, murdered by Australian William Thomas Douglas in Chiang Mai, Thailand
Hawaiian resident Gary Poretsky, murdered by Australian William Thomas Douglas in Chiang Mai, Thailand

Mr Poretsky, a native of Massachusetts but long time resident of Hawaii, was in Thailand for dental treatment where high quality dentistry is considerably more affordable than the USA.

The court was told that Mr Poretsky arranged to meet a Thai woman who he had met in Pai a week earlier for drinks at around 8pm on the evening of March 21.

The woman, who goes by the single name of Jirawadee, told the court that while she had drunk some beer, Mr Poretsky had only drunk water because he had been to the dentist for treatment earlier that day.

After the restaurant they had been drinking in closed the couple moved on to the Keari restaurant where again Mr Poretsky only drank water.

According to Jirawadee the couple noticed Douglas in the restaurant and Mr Poretsky invited him to join them. While Douglas spoke to Mr Poretsky in English, he spoke in fluent Thai with Ms Jirawadee.

Undercover policeman for the Thai police force

William Thomas Douglas attempts to shield his face as he is lead into court
William Thomas Douglas attempts to shield his face as he is lead into court. Photo: John Le Fevre
William Thomas Douglas talks with family members on his way into court in Chiang Mai
William Thomas Douglas talks with family members on his way into court in Chiang Mai. Photo: John Le Fevre

She said not long before the shooting Douglas had told Mr Poretsky and her that he worked as an undercover police operative for the Royal Thai Police Force, assisting them in identifying and capturing drug traffickers and users.

“He said he had already killed two drug traffickers while working with the police,” Ms Jirawadee said.

According to Ms Jirawadee, Mr Poretsky didn’t believe him and to prove his point Douglas pulled out a handgun and showed them.

“I couldn’t really understand a lot of what they were talking about, but after he showed the gun the conversation got tense and I went to ask the restaurant manager to help because the gun made me frightened,” she said.

She said “Douglas then left the table and a few minutes later returned. He pulled out the gun and shot Gary two times in the chest. Gary fell to the ground and then Douglas fired a third shot into his head.”

Ms Jirawadee described Mr Poretsky as “a nice friendly person. I never saw him get aggressive or raise his voice to anyone.”

Douglas told the court that he had lived in Thailand for 28 years and that prior to moving to Thailand he was a soldier in the Australian army. He said he had completed two tours of duty in Vietnam before coming to Thailand to teach English.

He said that Mr Poretsky had antagonised him by criticising the Vietnam War and had said “Australia should not have followed the US into the Vietnam War and that Australia and Thailand were dictated to by the US.”

Douglas had previously told the court that at the time of the shooting he was estranged from his Burmese girlfriend and living in a hotel. “I left the table and tried to telephone my ‘wife’ but her phone was turned off.

“When I returned Poretsky again claimed Australia and Thailand are tools of the US and should not have sent troops to the Vietnam War. I pulled out my gun and shot him, but at the time I didn’t know what I was doing,” Douglas claimed.

Douglas, who was supported by family members from Australia who flew to Chiang Mai for the trial, told the judge the shooting was out of character for him and he had previously not had any trouble with the police in either Australia or Thailand. He submitted a wad of character references from family and friends to support this.

I consider myself Thai, not Australian: – William Thomas Douglas in Chiang Mai

Chief Justice Chayut Prapakamon asked Douglas how long a sentence he would receive for a similar crime in Australia to which Douglas replied, “I’ve lived half my life in Australia and half my life in Thailand. I don’t know about Australian sentencing laws. I consider myself Thai now, not Australian.”

Chiang Mai Chief Public Prosecutor, Sonthaya Kruewate, asked for four years jail for Australian William Thomas Douglas
Chiang Mai Chief Public Prosecutor, Sonthaya Kruewate, asked for four years jail for Australian William Thomas Douglas. Photo: John Le Fevre
Paid Bt100,000 - the mystery girlfriend with a checkered backgound
Paid Bt100,000 – the mystery girlfriend with a checkered backgound. Photo John Le Fevre

When Justice Chayut then asked Douglas how long he thought he should be imprisoned for, Douglas replied, “six months.”

Justice Chayut claimed this was insufficient and told Douglas “Thai law states that for murder the penalty is death, or between 15 and 25 years imprisonment.

When Justice Chayut asked for a sentencing recommendation from Provincial Public Prosecutor Sonthaya Kruewate, the reply was, “four years.”

A woman who claimed she had been the girlfriend of Mr Poretsky and had known him several months earlier told the court in unsworn testimony that Mr Poretsky had planned to build a house for her and now she was left with a debt and couldn’t pay for building the house.

At the time of the shooting the investigating officer, captain Somsak Pamthong, said Mr Poretsky had only been in Thailand for two weeks. Friends of Mr Poretsky confirmed that and said he had not visited Thailand for at least 15 years.

Immediately following the shooting Capt. Somsak said Douglas had told him during questioning that he had shot Mr Poretsky “because he doesn’t like Americans. He thinks ‘they talk down to everyone and consider themselves better than everyone.'”

Prior to being sentenced and in open court in front of Justice Chayut, Douglas paid the woman, who goes by the name of Kanlayawan and was dressed in a dental nurses uniform, Bt100,000 in cash.

After seeing the payment Justice Chayut then read the sentence for the three charges and then immediately left the court.

On hearing the sentence Douglas burst into a broad grin and cheerfully told his family and friends the sentence meant he would serve only two years and nine months minus the time he has been held in remand.

As he was escorted back to the court holding cells Douglas had difficulty keeping his grin under control – a stark contrast to earlier in the day when he had gone to great lengths to hide his face from waiting camera crews.

ENDS:
© John Le Fevre, 2008

June 14, 2010.

William Thomas Douglas was granted a royal pardon by HM King Bhumibol Adulyadej during the week of June 7, cutting six months off his sentence. He is resisting deportation procedures in order to remain in the kingdom where he is married to a Thai woman.

See: Video footage of the crime scene and William Thomas Douglas’ on-camera confession

See: Video of William Thomas Douglas’ court attendance

Related: Family of murdered American tourist call for Thailand travel boycott

Related: Aussie shooter front’s Thai Court

Related: Perth man remanded over fatal shooting of American tourist

Related: American tourist not liked – killed

Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape

Chiang Mai • Corruption • Gary Bruce Poretsky • Murder • Thailand • Tourist Murder • William Thomas Douglas • Thailand legal system • Crime • Thailand • Northern Thailand • Vietnam War • Vietnam Veteran

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Was this quality content? Please rate
Rating: 4.9/5 (17 votes cast)

Cash payment lightens sentence for Australian murderer (Updated June 14, 2010), 4.9 out of 5 based on 17 ratings

The following two tabs change content below.

John Le Fevre

Deputy editor, Thailand & GMS editor at The Establishment Post

John Le Fevre is an Australian national with more than 35 years experience as a journalist, photographer, videographer and copy editor.

He is currently deputy editor and Thailand / GMS region editor for The Establishment Post

Opinions and views expressed on this site are those of the author’s only. Read more at About me

7 Responses to "Cash payment lightens sentence for Australian murderer (Updated June 14, 2010)"

  1. Forex Programming   August 23, 2011 at 7:29 pm

    Frankly, I’m American and this story disgusts me. It would have disgusted me even if the nationalities were reversed. However, I fear there is nothing that can really be done by me to keep this man in jail. Letter writing isn’t going to do it, unless it is really a heavily organized movement that gets some serious media coverage involved

    Forex Programming

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
    Reply
  2. brian   January 5, 2010 at 4:13 pm

    there is a special place in hell for such slimy monsters as mr douglas. this case just shows in broad daylight how corrupt the thai injustice system is. judge and prosecutor should be thrown in jail for this.
    Absolutely sickening.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
    Reply
  3. Tyler Harrison   July 23, 2009 at 6:21 am

    hello to all the readers of this news bulletin there is a few things Id like to say. I knew gary but I knew him as 2dog but anyway he was a very nice guy kind caring friendly man and he was not cocky in any way. and as for this austrailian who thinks hes thai hes retarted for thinking that he should only have to serve 2 months in prison the fact of the matter is he had intent to kill him he said so in his confession by saying and I quote ‚Äúbecause he doesn‚Äôt like Americans. He thinks ‚Äòthey talk down to everyone and consider themselves better than everyone.‚Äô‚Äù which in some cases can be true but I new gary and he is not the kind of man to down-talk another person and furthermore the man was grinning when he was given his sentance which makes me think he new more then he is telling and on top of that the so called “girlfriend”????? is married with kids and only met gary a week before this happend and was given money?????? to me this seems a little suspicious and it states in thai law that murder will give u life in prison or 15-20 yrs and hes getting nothing near that to me this seems a little fishy and in my opinion someone as foolhardy and downright racist as him should be put to death for being stupid and ignorant. but aside from that it almost seems as though he did something for someone to get him off maybe even the government but in any case this man has not been served justice and me and many of his friends on the big island of hawaii would like to see this man in his grave as sson as possible and if there is anyone out there who thinks the same tell them so he get what he deserves. life rotting away in a prison cell and eventually death. thank you for time and I hope justice will be served. aloha

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
    Reply
  4. Joshua   May 7, 2009 at 7:02 pm

    Frankly, I’m American and this story disgusts me. It would have disgusted me even if the nationalities were reversed. However, I fear there is nothing that can really be done by me to keep this man in jail. Letter writing isn’t going to do it, unless it is really a heavily organized movement that gets some serious media coverage involved.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
    Reply
  5. Sandee   March 29, 2009 at 9:33 pm

    This is some sort of joke – right?

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
    Reply
    • John Le Fevre   March 29, 2009 at 9:40 pm

      Hello Sandee and thanks for reading. Unfortunately it’s not a joke. I hope that from reading the story and the comments posted by other people you have a faily good understanding of what has transpired here. I have never heard of anyone receiving a sentence such as this in Thailand for murder and the actions of the US Government leading up to and post-trial can only leave citizens of the US wondering how much their government cares about them.

      VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
      Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
      Reply
  6. lucathai67   October 6, 2008 at 3:52 pm

    I had some information about that girl that got the (the one in the photo)money from the murder , she does not wear a nurse uniform but a doghouse one…she is married , she has two kids and the thai husband used to take her to sell the body in the *** **** bar every evening…poor Gary , this woman is a volture !!!
    She met Gary few month ago in the bar, Gary was a kind of generous and genuine guy , he liked this girl but he did not know which kind of person she is…(a lower prostitute class) she probabaly wanted to “cook slow flame” Gary and convince him to buy a house for her…obviously she did not tell him that she is married and has two kids…so all she want from Gary was just to cheat him !It’s happened many times that foreigner guys met those bar girls bought a house …and once they go to their country for few weeks …the women sell the house and disappear with the cash !Is a very common story over here !

    Before I do not trust much the thai law …but now i do not trust it at all…plus i feel very unsafe !!!

    I am very sad for Gary , he done nothing to this Australian guy and he was murdered with atrocity , what is worst is the sentence…less than 3 years ! Its seem that the is no justice in this part of the world !

    The name of the bar has been deleted for privacy reasons – John Le Fevre

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
    Reply

Leave a Reply